In the Supreme Court, the Eknath Shinde faction argued that “dissent is not defection”. The petitions challenge the Speaker’s 2024 decision not to disqualify these MLAs under the Tenth Schedule. The Tenth Schedule is the anti-defection law. It was added by the 52nd Amendment, 1985. A member of a House loses the seat if he or she: Voluntarily gives up membership of the party. Votes or stays away from voting against the party’s order (whip), unless the party forgives it within 15 days. An independent member is disqualified for joining a party. A nominated member is disqualified for joining a party after six months. There is no disqualification if two-thirds of a party’s members agree to merge with another party. The 91st Amendment, 2003 removed the old rule that protected a split by one-third of members. The Speaker or Chairman decides these cases. In Kihoto Hollohan (1992), the Supreme Court said this decision can be reviewed by courts. The law sets no time limit for the Speaker to decide. “The President decides if an MP is disqualified under the Tenth Schedule.” This is incorrect. The Speaker or Chairman decides. (UPSC Prelims 2025) “The word ‘political party’ is not used anywhere in the Constitution.” This is incorrect. The Tenth Schedule uses it. (UPSC Prelims 2025) “A nominated member cannot join a party within six months.” This is incorrect. He or she can join within six months. Joining after six months leads to disqualification. (UPSC Prelims 2022)Why in News
Prelims Pointers
Prelims Traps
Polity
Shiv Sena row: dissent is not defection, says Shinde faction to SC
The Hindu